Advantages and Disadvantages of Constant-Force Technical Springs

Constant-force technical springs are a type of mechanical spring that offer unique advantages and disadvantages in various applications. This article will explore the features, benefits, and drawbacks of constant-force technical springs, providing a comprehensive understanding of their capabilities and limitations.

Want more information on custom made automotive coil springs? Feel free to contact us.

What are Constant-Force Technical Springs?

Constant-force technical springs, also known as constant-force springs, are mechanical devices designed to exert a constant amount of force over a specific linear distance. They are often made from durable materials such as stainless steel or carbon steel and are widely used in the automotive, aerospace, medical, and electronics industries.

These springs work on the principle of tightly coiling a flat strip of material onto a drum or shaft. As the strip is unwound, the spring applies a consistent force throughout the extension, maintaining a steady force-to-distance relationship.

Advantages of Constant-Force Technical Springs

Constant-force technical springs offer several advantages that make them popular in many applications. Let’s delve into the benefits they provide:

1. Constant Force Output

One of the key advantages of constant-force technical springs is their ability to deliver a consistent force output over a specified distance. This constant and linear force is particularly valuable in applications requiring a steady and predictable force, such as retractable cords, counterbalancing systems, and electrical contacts.

Constant-force technical springs ensure that the force exerted remains constant regardless of the extension length. This feature is crucial for applications that require a reliable and predictable force, as it eliminates the need for complex force calculations and adjustments. The consistent force output these springs provide promotes smooth and reliable operation, minimizing the risk of malfunction or damage.

2. High Force Density

Constant-force springs can generate much force relative to their size and weight. Their ability to provide a substantial force output within a compact and lightweight design makes them ideal for space-constrained applications where weight and size limitations exist.

The high force density of constant-force technical springs allows for efficient use of limited space. These springs can deliver significant force even in confined areas, making them suitable for applications where size and weight are critical factors. Their compact design also enables easy integration into various systems without compromising performance.

3. Long Extension Lengths

Unlike traditional coil springs, constant-force springs can achieve long extension lengths without sacrificing force output. With the ability to extend up to several meters without compromising performance, these springs are well-suited for applications that require a significant range of motion.

The long extension capability of constant-force technical springs enables them to accommodate large displacements and provide a constant force throughout the entire range of motion. This feature is especially beneficial in applications such as retractable cables or cords requiring a long extension length. Maintaining a consistent force even at extended lengths ensures reliable and efficient operation.

4. Smooth and Precise Motion

The design of constant-force technical springs allows for smooth and controlled motion. They minimize jerks, vibrations, and sudden changes in force during extension and retraction, which is crucial in applications requiring precise and consistent movement, such as tape measures, window blinds, and door closers.

Constant-force springs provide a gradual and controlled force delivery, resulting in smooth and precise motion. This feature enhances the overall performance and accuracy of systems utilizing these springs. The absence of abrupt changes in force during operation reduces the risk of damage or instability, ensuring reliable and safe operation.

5. Reduced Fatigue and Wear

Constant-force springs are designed to distribute the load evenly across the entire length of the strip. This balanced load distribution minimizes localized stress concentrations, reducing the risk of fatigue failure and extending the spring’s lifespan. The smooth unwinding and winding action reduces wear and tear, ensuring long-term reliability.

The even distribution of forces in constant-force technical springs minimizes the occurrence of stress concentrations, which can lead to premature fatigue failure. These springs maintain a balanced force distribution by evenly distributing the load, reducing the likelihood of localized damage or wear. The smooth and controlled motion of the springs further contributes to their longevity, as it minimizes friction and abrasion.

6. Customizable Options

Constant-force technical springs can be customized to suit specific requirements. Manufacturers can adjust material type, width, thickness, and length to achieve the desired force characteristics. This flexibility allows for tailored solutions that meet the precise needs of diverse applications.

The customizable nature of constant-force technical springs enables manufacturers to fine-tune the force characteristics according to the specific requirements of each application. By selecting the appropriate material, dimensions, and configuration, the performance of these springs can be optimized for various operating conditions. This customization capability ensures that constant-force springs can seamlessly integrate into various systems, enhancing overall functionality and efficiency.

Disadvantages of Constant-Force Technical Springs

While constant-force technical springs offer numerous benefits, it is essential to consider their limitations and potential drawbacks. Let’s explore some of the challenges associated with the use of these springs:

1. Fixed Force Characteristics

While advantageous in many applications, the constant-force output of these springs can also be a limitation. In variable force requirements, constant-force springs may not be suitable. Any changes in the desired force would necessitate different springs or additional mechanisms.

The fixed force characteristic of constant-force technical springs limits their adaptability to applications with variable force requirements. If the desired force output changes, replace the existing spring with a different one or incorporate additional mechanisms to achieve the desired variability. This limitation should be carefully considered when selecting constant-force springs for applications that require adjustable force levels.

2. Initial Tensioning

To achieve the desired output, constant-force springs require proper initial tensioning during installation. This process can be relatively complex, requiring specialized knowledge and tools. Improper tensioning may result in inconsistent force output or premature failure.

Proper initial tensioning is crucial for the optimal performance of constant-force technical springs. It involves carefully adjusting the preload to ensure the spring exerts the desired force throughout its extension range. This process may require specialized tools and expertise, as improper tensioning can lead to inconsistent force output or premature failure. Therefore, following manufacturer guidelines and seeking professional assistance when installing these springs is essential.

3. Limited Flexibility

Constant-force springs have a linear force-to-distance relationship, and their flexibility is limited to this specific characteristic. While they excel in applications that require a steady force output, their use may be impractical or inefficient in situations where non-linear force delivery is necessary.

The linear force-to-distance relationship of constant-force technical springs restricts their applicability to systems that require non-linear force delivery. Constant-force springs may not provide the desired performance in applications with varying force requirements over the extension range. Other springs or mechanisms that accommodate non-linear force characteristics may be more suitable for such applications.

4. Cost Considerations

Constant-force technical springs can be more expensive than traditional coil springs due to their complex manufacturing process and customized nature. The materials used, the precision required, and the customization options contribute to the higher costs associated with these springs. However, their long lifespan and reliability often justify the initial investment.

The complex manufacturing process and customization options of constant-force technical springs contribute to their relatively higher cost than traditional coil springs. The selection of high-quality materials and the precision required in their production further adds to the manufacturing expenses. However, these springs’ long lifespan and reliability often outweigh the initial investment, making them a cost-effective choice in the long run.

Conclusion

Constant-force technical springs offer numerous advantages in their constant force output, high force density, long extension lengths, smooth motion, reduced fatigue, and customizable options. However, they also come with limitations, including fixed force characteristics, initial tensioning requirements, limited flexibility, and higher costs than traditional springs.

By understanding the advantages and disadvantages of constant-force technical springs, engineers, designers, and manufacturers can make informed decisions when selecting the appropriate springs for their applications. Ultimately, with careful consideration of these factors, constant-force springs can greatly enhance the performance and reliability of various mechanical systems.

FAQ

Q1: What are constant-force technical springs?

A1: Constant-force technical springs are mechanical devices that exert constant force over a specific linear distance. They are widely used in the automotive, aerospace, medical, and electronics industries.

Q2: What are the advantages of constant-force technical springs?

A2:

• Constant force output: They deliver a consistent force over a specified distance, ensuring reliable and predictable operation.
• High force density: They generate high force relative to their size and weight, making them ideal for space-constrained applications.
• Long extension lengths: They can achieve long extensions without sacrificing force output, accommodating large displacements.
• Smooth and precise motion: They provide controlled and smooth motion, minimizing jerks and sudden changes in force.

Q3: What are the disadvantages of constant-force technical springs?

A3:

• Fixed force characteristics: They have a fixed force output, which limits their adaptability to applications with variable force requirements.
• Initial tensioning: They require proper initial tensioning during installation, which can be complex and may result in inconsistent force output if done improperly.
• Limited flexibility: They have a linear force-to-distance relationship, making them impractical for applications that require non-linear force delivery.
• Cost considerations: They can be more expensive than traditional coil springs due to their complex manufacturing process and customization options.

Q4: Can constant-force technical springs be customized?

A4: Constant-force technical springs can be customized to suit specific requirements. Factors such as material type, width, thickness, and length can be adjusted to achieve the desired force characteristics, allowing for tailored solutions that meet the precise needs of different applications.

If you are unsatisfied with aspects of your car, such as handling and performance, ride height and stiffness, control and stability while cornering and its appearance, you might benefit from switching your car to coilover suspension.

However, to know for sure whether coilover suspension is the right option for you, you need to be aware of the pros and cons of coilover suspension. We will cover that topic in this article. 

What is coilover suspension?

Coilover suspension is a type of suspension system used in vehicles, particularly high-performance and sports cars, that combines a shock absorber and a coil spring into a single unit. Depending on the vehicle, sometimes a separate spring and shock absorber may be used, but offers higher performance over the standard suspension.

In a coilover suspension system, the spring is seated over the shock absorber, which is mounted to the vehicle's chassis. The height and stiffness of the spring can be adjusted to modify the vehicle's ride height and handling characteristics, making coilover suspension a popular choice for those looking to improve their vehicle's performance and aesthetics.

Contact us to discuss your requirements of custom automotive coil springs. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.

Coilover suspension is generally considered to be more customisable and higher-performing than standard or OEM suspension systems, however may sacrifice some comfort, depending on spring rates and damping tune.

What are the pros of coilover suspension?

Improved handling and performance

Coilover suspension improves handling and performance in several ways. For example, coilover suspension can help distribute weight more evenly across the vehicle, improving overall balance and stability. This is particularly important during high-speed cornering, where weight distribution can greatly affect the vehicle's handling.

It is also designed to reduce body roll, which is the side-to-side motion of the vehicle during cornering. By minimising body roll, the suspension can keep the vehicle more stable and better in control.

Additionally, coilovers provide more precise control over the vehicle's movements than traditional suspension systems. This is because the spring and shock absorber are designed to work together, providing more consistent and predictable suspension behaviour.

Coilover suspension can also improve the vehicle's grip on the road, particularly during cornering. This is because the suspension is better able to maintain contact with the road surface, ensuring that the tires stay in contact with the ground.

Customisable ride height and stiffness

Coilover suspension improves ride height and stiffness by allowing for easy adjustment of the height and stiffness of the vehicle's suspension system. The compression or extension of the spring wrapped around the shock absorber determines the ride height, while its stiffness determines the suspension's firmness.

To adjust the ride height, the coilover system allows you to change the height of the threaded sleeve that sits on the shock absorber. By rotating the sleeve up or down, you can adjust the position of the spring and thereby raise or lower the ride height of the vehicle.

To adjust the stiffness of the suspension, you can adjust the preload on the spring. This involves compressing or expanding the spring before installation to set the initial load. By increasing or decreasing the preload, you can make the suspension softer or stiffer.

These adjustments allow you to customise your vehicle's suspension to your specific performance needs.

However, it is important to note that these adjustments can affect the vehicle's handling and should be done carefully and with proper knowledge of how they will impact the vehicle's performance.

Better control and stability during cornering

Coilover suspension improves control and stability during cornering by providing better weight transfer and reducing body roll.

During cornering, a vehicle's weight shifts towards the outside of the turn, which can cause the inside wheels to lift off the ground, reducing traction and stability. Coilover suspension helps to counteract this by providing a stiffer and more responsive suspension, which helps to keep the wheels in contact with the road surface. This improves traction and stability, allowing the driver to maintain better control of the vehicle through corners.

In addition, coilover suspension also helps to reduce body roll, which is the tendency of a vehicle's body to lean to one side during cornering. This is because the stiffer springs and dampers in a coilover suspension system are better able to resist the forces that cause body roll, resulting in a flatter and more stable ride through corners.

Vehicle appearance

Coilover suspension can enhance the appearance of a vehicle by providing greater control over ride height, which can make the car look more aggressive and sporty, and by allowing for improved wheel fitment for the installation of wider wheels and tires, which can make the car look more custom and performance-oriented.

What are the cons of coilover suspension?

Higher cost compared to traditional suspension systems

The higher cost of coilover suspension systems is typically justified by their improved handling and performance, customisation options, and increased durability and longevity. However, it's important to weigh the costs and benefits of coilover suspension against your specific needs and budget.

For example, coilover suspension systems typically use higher quality materials and components, such as stiffer springs, adjustable dampers, and stronger mounts. These components are designed to withstand the additional stress and forces generated by high-performance driving and racing, which can increase their cost.

Additionally, coilover suspension systems are designed to be customised to meet your specific needs. This requires more engineering, testing, and development time